Larry's Italian Pantry: What to Buy, Shelf by Shelf

Last updated

Short answer

Start with extra virgin olive oil, canned whole peeled tomatoes, passata, two or three dried pasta shapes, risotto rice, canned beans, anchovies, capers, olives, a wedge of Parmigiano-Reggiano or Pecorino Romano, dried oregano, red pepper flakes and fennel seed. Add 00 flour and yeast for pizza night. Read labels for 'extra virgin', protected names like DOP, and short ingredient lists.

This is the shopping list for an Italian kitchen, organized the way a pantry is: by shelf. For every item you get what it's for, what to look for on the label, and which recipes on this site use it. There are links to search Amazon and Amazon Fresh, but there are no prices, because grocery prices change too fast to print. Amazon Fresh isn't available everywhere, and this list works just as well at any good Italian grocery, deli or supermarket.

As an Amazon Associate, Uncle Larry Adventures earns from qualifying purchases. Links on this page go to Amazon searches, not single products, and we don't list prices.

Amazon Fresh isn't available everywhere. Every item here is also sold at any good Italian grocery, deli or supermarket.

Buying for someone else? The Italian Gift Finder picks one in four questions.

The shelves

Oils and vinegars

The bottles you reach for every night: one oil to cook with, and vinegars for salads, peppers and pan sauces.

Balsamic vinegar of Modena

What it's for

A few drops on tomatoes, strawberries, grilled vegetables or a wedge of Parmigiano.

What to look for

  • 'Aceto Balsamico di Modena IGP' for the everyday kind
  • 'Tradizionale DOP' for the aged, sipping-thick kind, which costs far more
  • A short ingredient list: grape must and wine vinegar

Used in

Tomatoes and jarred goods

The Sunday gravy shelf, plus the small salty jars that turn a plain pasta into puttanesca.

Canned whole peeled tomatoes

What it's for

The base of marinara, gravy and pizza sauce. Crush them by hand for the best texture.

What to look for

  • Whole peeled tomatoes rather than diced, which hold their shape and won't break down
  • For San Marzano, the protected name 'Pomodoro San Marzano dell'Agro Sarnese-Nocerino DOP' on the can
  • Tomatoes and maybe basil and salt; nothing else needed

Used in

Tuna in olive oil

What it's for

A pantry dinner: tossed with tomatoes, capers and pasta, or on a salad.

What to look for

  • Packed in olive oil, not water, for Italian dishes
  • Jars or cans of solid pieces

Used in

Pasta, rice and grains

Three or four pasta shapes, a bag of risotto rice and some beans cover most nights of the week.

Polenta

What it's for

Soft and creamy under sausage or ragù, or cooled, sliced and grilled.

What to look for

  • Traditional coarse-ground cornmeal takes longer; 'instant' or 'quick' cooks in minutes
  • Check the cooking time on the bag

Used in

Cheese and cured meats

Kept in the fridge, not the cupboard, but part of every Italian pantry. Fresh and chilled items are usually easiest to buy at a local deli or grocery.

Spices and dried herbs

A short spice shelf. Fresh garlic, onions, lemons, parsley and basil come from the produce aisle.

Fennel seed

What it's for

The signature flavor of 'sweet' Italian sausage. Crush a pinch into sauce or homemade sausage.

What to look for

  • Whole seeds, crushed as you need them
  • Green-tinged seeds are fresher than gray ones

Used in

Baking

For pizza night, fresh pasta, focaccia and the tiramisù that ends it all.

Savoiardi (ladyfingers)

What it's for

The crisp Italian ladyfingers for tiramisù.

What to look for

  • Crisp, dry savoiardi, not soft sponge ladyfingers
  • Imported Italian packs are widely sold

Used in

How to use this list

Build a recipe's shopping list with the 'Add to my shopping list' button on any recipe. The shopping list then points back here for the pantry items in it, so you can check what to look for before you buy.

Oils and vinegars

The bottles you reach for every night: one oil to cook with, and vinegars for salads, peppers and pan sauces. On this shelf: Extra virgin olive oil, Balsamic vinegar of Modena, Red wine vinegar.

Tomatoes and jarred goods

The Sunday gravy shelf, plus the small salty jars that turn a plain pasta into puttanesca. On this shelf: Canned whole peeled tomatoes, Passata (strained tomato purée), Tomato paste, Anchovies, Capers, Olives, Calabrian chiles in oil, Tuna in olive oil.

Pasta, rice and grains

Three or four pasta shapes, a bag of risotto rice and some beans cover most nights of the week. On this shelf: Dried pasta, Risotto rice, Polenta, Cannellini beans and chickpeas.

Cheese and cured meats

Kept in the fridge, not the cupboard, but part of every Italian pantry. Fresh and chilled items are usually easiest to buy at a local deli or grocery. On this shelf: Parmigiano-Reggiano, Pecorino Romano, Guanciale or pancetta.

Spices and dried herbs

A short spice shelf. Fresh garlic, onions, lemons, parsley and basil come from the produce aisle. On this shelf: Dried oregano, Red pepper flakes, Fennel seed, Saffron.

Baking

For pizza night, fresh pasta, focaccia and the tiramisù that ends it all. On this shelf: '00' flour, Semolina (semola rimacinata), Instant yeast, Breadcrumbs, Savoiardi (ladyfingers).

Where to shop if Amazon Fresh doesn't deliver to you

Any Italian deli or grocery will carry nearly everything here, often with better cheese and cured meat counters. A good supermarket covers the rest: look in the international aisle for passata, anchovies, capers and savoiardi, and at the deli counter for Parmigiano-Reggiano and pancetta.

Common questions

What are the essential Italian pantry items to buy first?
Extra virgin olive oil, canned whole peeled tomatoes, dried pasta, garlic and a hard grating cheese like Parmigiano-Reggiano or Pecorino Romano. With those you can make dozens of dishes.
Are imported Italian ingredients worth the price?
For a few items, the label matters most: protected names like Parmigiano Reggiano DOP and Pecorino Romano DOP, extra virgin olive oil with a recent date, and San Marzano DOP tomatoes if you want them. For pasta, beans and spices, a good domestic brand is fine.
Why doesn't this page list prices?
Grocery prices and listings change daily, so any number printed here would soon be wrong. Check the current listing or your local store.
Can I buy these at a regular grocery store?
Yes. Every item on this list is sold at Italian delis and many supermarkets. The Amazon and Amazon Fresh links are a convenience, not a requirement.
Should Parmigiano and guanciale be bought online?
They're chilled, so a local deli or cheese counter is often the easiest choice. If you order them, check the delivery and packaging terms.

Make it

More straight answers

Cite this guide: “Larry's Italian Pantry: What to Buy, Shelf by Shelf” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/italian-pantry-shopping-guide

Next up

Keep going — a recipe to try, a film to watch, and an answer to the question you were about to search.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.