Anchovies and Capers in Italian Cooking

Last updated

Short answer

Melt a few oil-packed anchovy fillets into warm olive oil with garlic and they dissolve into a savory base, not a fishy taste. Salt-packed anchovies need rinsing and filleting first. Rinse brined capers; soak salt-packed capers 10–20 minutes. Use both in puttanesca, piccata, caponata and salsa verde.

Anchovies and capers are the quiet workers of the Italian kitchen. Most people who swear they hate anchovies have eaten them happily, dissolved into a sauce. A few fillets and a spoon of capers add salt, depth and brightness that you'd otherwise chase with a lot more ingredients. Here's how to buy them, prep them and use them.

Oil-packed or salt-packed anchovies

Oil-packed fillets in tins or jars are ready to use: lift out, pat dry and go. Salt-packed whole anchovies, often sold in larger tins, are meatier but need work: rinse off the salt, split them, pull out the spine and soak briefly if they're very salty. After opening, keep anchovies covered with oil or salt in the fridge and follow the label for how long.

Melt them into the base

Warm olive oil gently with garlic, add the fillets and stir over low heat for a minute or two; they melt into the oil. That's the start of puttanesca, many broccoli rabe pastas and a lot of Italian-American red sauces. Keep the heat low: frying anchovies hard turns them bitter. Anchovy paste in a tube is convenient for small amounts.

Capers: brined or salted

Capers are the pickled flower buds of the caper bush. Brined capers, the most common in the US, should be drained and rinsed. Salt-packed capers, prized in southern Italy, have a cleaner, more floral flavor; rinse and soak them 10–20 minutes, then taste. Small nonpareil capers are delicate; larger ones are bolder. Caperberries are the plant's fruit, eaten whole like olives.

Where they go

Puttanesca uses both. Chicken piccata finishes with capers and lemon. Caponata balances sweet-sour eggplant with capers and olives. Salsa verde is herbs, capers and anchovy. Add capers near the end so they stay bright, or fry drained capers in oil for a crisp garnish.

Salt check

Both are salty. Add them before you salt the dish, then taste and adjust. Pasta water for an anchovy sauce can be salted a little more lightly than usual.

Common questions

Do anchovies make food taste fishy?
Not when melted gently into oil or sauce. They dissolve and add savory depth. Whole fillets on pizza or a salad taste more of the sea.
Can I substitute anchovy paste for fillets?
Yes. About 1/2 teaspoon of paste stands in for one fillet, roughly. Taste, since brands vary in saltiness.
Do I need to rinse capers?
Rinse brined capers, and rinse and soak salt-packed ones. Unrinsed, they can over-salt the dish.
What's the difference between capers and caperberries?
Capers are flower buds; caperberries are the larger fruit that forms after the flower, usually served whole with the stem.
What can I use instead of anchovies?
For a vegetarian swap, a little miso, chopped olives or extra capers adds salty depth. It won't taste identical.

Make it

More straight answers

Cite this guide: “Anchovies and Capers in Italian Cooking” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/anchovies-and-capers

Next up

Keep going — a recipe to try, a film to watch, and an answer to the question you were about to search.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.