Trust & methodology

How We Score

Last updated

Every sausage and peppers review is scored 1–10 in five categories: sausage (30%), pepper and onion (20%), sauce and flavor balance (20%), bread (15%) and value (15%). The total is the weighted average, so a street-fair stand and a sit-down trattoria are judged on the same scale.

The five categories

1. Sausage quality 30%

What we look for: Snap of the casing, juiciness, seasoning (fennel, garlic, heat) and a proper sear. It should taste made with care, not boiled and forgotten.

  • 9–10 — Casing snaps, interior juicy, seasoning distinct and a deep brown sear.
  • 7–8 — Juicy and well seasoned with one small miss, like an uneven sear.
  • 5–6 — Fine but generic: mild seasoning, pale or slightly dry.
  • 3–4 — Dry, rubbery or under-seasoned.
  • 1–2 — Grey, greasy-dry or undercooked. Skip it.

2. Pepper & onion cook 20%

What we look for: Peppers soft but holding shape, onions sweet and jammy, some caramelized edges. Not steamed, grey or raw-crunchy.

  • 9–10 — Silky peppers, jammy onions, real browning on the edges.
  • 7–8 — Tender and sweet, a little short on caramelization.
  • 5–6 — Cooked through but steamed and flat.
  • 3–4 — Mushy or still crunchy-raw.
  • 1–2 — Grey, watery or burnt.

3. Bread 15%

What we look for: A roll that holds the juices without collapsing, with real crust and chew. Marked N/A for plated versions served without bread.

  • 9–10 — Crisp crust, chewy crumb, holds to the last bite.
  • 7–8 — Good roll that softens a bit by the end.
  • 5–6 — Soft supermarket-style roll that gets soggy.
  • 3–4 — Falls apart or is stale.
  • 1–2 — Unusable: soaked through or dried out.

4. Sauce & flavor balance 20%

What we look for: Salt, fat, acid and heat in balance, whether that's tomato, vinegar peppers or just pan juices. Every bite should taste finished.

  • 9–10 — Every element in balance; nothing needs fixing.
  • 7–8 — Balanced, with one element slightly loud or quiet.
  • 5–6 — Noticeably too salty, oily, sweet or flat.
  • 3–4 — One element dominates the whole plate.
  • 1–2 — Unbalanced to the point of hard to finish.

5. Value 15%

What we look for: Portion and quality relative to the price paid on the day of the visit. Cheap isn't automatically good value; great food can earn a high price.

  • 9–10 — Generous and excellent for the price; you'd pay more.
  • 7–8 — Fair price for what you get.
  • 5–6 — A little steep or a little small.
  • 3–4 — Clearly overpriced for the portion or quality.
  • 1–2 — Poor value by any measure.

The 1–10 scale

Half points are allowed. Each category is scored on its own before the total is worked out.

Worked example

A made-up sandwich stand, to show the math. It is not a real restaurant or review.

CategoryScoreWeightPoints
Sausage quality8× 0.302.400
Pepper & onion cook7× 0.201.400
Bread7.5× 0.151.125
Sauce & flavor balance8× 0.201.600
Value9× 0.151.350
Total (rounded to one decimal)7.9

Strong sausage and great value carry this stand; the steamed-tasting peppers (7) are what keep it out of the 8s. If the same dish came plated with no bread, bread would be marked N/A and the other four weights scaled up to fill 100%: the same scores would total 7.9.

Sample entry — not a real review

Example Sausage Stand

Sample City · Visited —

7.9 / 10

Sausage quality (30%)
8/10
Pepper & onion cook (20%)
7/10
Bread (15%)
7.5/10
Sauce & flavor balance (20%)
8/10
Value (15%)
9/10

How we score →

Where scores are used

Scored visits appear on restaurant reviews, the city guides and the city rankings. A city is ranked only once at least three of its restaurants have a scored visit. Home-cooking experiments use a separate method: how we test.

Independence & disclosure

Corrections

Got a fact wrong — a closed restaurant, a changed menu, a bad address? Tell us through the contact page. We fix confirmed errors promptly and update the “Last updated” date on the page. If this rubric changes, the date at the top changes too.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.