Italian-American food · Map

Only in America

A map of regional Italian-American dishes

Order Utica greens in Chicago and you'll get a blank look. Plenty of Italian-American food belongs to one city: a neighborhood, a bakery, sometimes one family's kitchen. Here are 13 of them across 12 places, with where each comes from and who tells the story.

Last updated

The short answer

Some Italian-American dishes belong to one city: Utica greens (Utica, NY), Chicken French (Rochester, NY), the Italian hot dog (Newark, NJ), tomato pie (Trenton, NJ), the roast pork sandwich (Philadelphia), apizza (New Haven), pizza strips (Providence), the sausage and peppers hero (New York's street feasts), Italian beef (Chicago), toasted ravioli and St. Louis-style pizza (St. Louis), the muffuletta (New Orleans) and cioppino (San Francisco). Most origin stories rest on one restaurant's or family's account, so first-inventor claims are hedged and every stop cites its sources.

Loading map… every dish is listed below.

The dishes, place by place

Utica, New York

Utica greens

Escarole cooked with garlic, prosciutto and hot cherry peppers, finished with grated cheese and breadcrumbs.

The New York Times reports that Utica's Chesterfield Restaurant began serving the dish in 1988, and chef Joe Morelle is credited with popularizing it. In Utica it's often ordered as "greens Morelle." Versions now turn up on Italian-American menus across central New York.

Sources: The New York Times: Utica Greens, a central New York staple (2017); Gastronomica: Utica Greens, Central New York's Italian-American Specialty (2009)

Rochester, New York

Chicken French

An egg-battered chicken cutlet in a lemon, butter and white wine sauce. Rochester calls it Chicken French; most other places say chicken francese.

Rochester's Brown Derby restaurant, where Nate Cianciola and his brother Vincenzo cooked in the 1950s, is commonly credited with perfecting it, starting from Veal French. Veal versions were already on Italian-American menus elsewhere, so no single inventor is certain.

Sources: Fox Rochester: Signature Rochester dish earns national attention (2019); Democrat and Chronicle: The secrets of Chicken French (2024); Red Sauce America: A brief history of chicken francese (2025)

Newark, New Jersey

Italian hot dog

Fried hot dogs tucked into a wedge of round Italian "pizza bread" with fried peppers, onions and potatoes.

James Racioppi of Jimmy Buff's says his grandparents first made them for weekly card games in their Newark apartment, then opened a shop in 1932. That's a family account, and it's the best-known one.

Sources: Roadfood: Newark hot dog; The Daily Beast (Jane & Michael Stern): Jimmy Buff's (2014)

Trenton, New Jersey

Trenton tomato pie

A thin, round pie built backwards: cheese goes down first and the crushed tomatoes go on top.

Papa's Tomato Pies says it opened in Trenton in 1912 and calls itself the oldest family-owned pizzeria in the country. Don't mix it up with Philadelphia tomato pie, a thick, cheeseless sheet served at room temperature.

Sources: Papa's Tomato Pies: Our story; New Jersey Monthly: The Original (2010); Pizza Today: The Trenton tomato pie (2017)

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Roast pork sandwich

Slow-roasted pork shoulder, sliced or chopped, on a long roll with sharp provolone and garlicky broccoli rabe or spinach.

Plenty of Philadelphians rank it above the cheesesteak. Visit Philadelphia describes it as born from Italian-American cooking, and food writer Ian MacAllen traces it to Italian-American wedding catering about a century ago.

Sources: Visit Philadelphia: Roast pork sandwiches; Red Sauce America: The history of Philadelphia's Italian roast pork sandwich (2023)

New Haven, Connecticut

New Haven apizza

Thin, charred, chewy pizza from very hot ovens, said locally as "ah-beetz."

Frank Pepe, an immigrant from southern Italy, opened his pizzeria on Wooster Street in 1925. The pizzeria says the first menu was a pie of tomatoes, pecorino, garlic, oregano and olive oil, plus one with anchovies.

Sources: Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana: About us; New England Historical Society: The birth of New Haven's white clam apizza

Providence, Rhode Island

Pizza strips

Rectangles of thick bakery dough under a heavy layer of tomato sauce, no cheese, eaten at room temperature.

Rhode Island's Italian bakeries sell them by the box for parties, ballgames and beach days. Nobody is firmly credited with inventing them. D. Palmieri's, one of the oldest bakeries selling them, traces the family bakery to Providence in 1905.

Sources: Saveur: Rhode Island pizza strips (2025); Red Sauce America: The history of Rhode Island's pizza strips (2024); Rhode Island Monthly: Where to get pizza strips (2022)

New York City (Little Italy)

Sausage and peppers hero

Grilled Italian sausage with soft peppers and onions on a long roll.

It's one of the famous foods of the Feast of San Gennaro, which began as a one-day block party on Mulberry Street in 1926 and now runs 11 days. You'll find it at Italian-American street feasts in many other cities too. Larry's history page covers what is and isn't known about where it started.

Sources: Feast of San Gennaro: History; CBS New York: Feast of San Gennaro 2026

Chicago, Illinois (Taylor Street)

Italian beef

Thin-sliced seasoned roast beef soaked in its juices on a long roll, topped with hot giardiniera or sweet peppers.

The Culinary Historians of Chicago trace it to the Taylor Street neighborhood, where it first became a fast food, and to southern Italian ways of serving roast meat at family celebrations. Several shops claim to be first; WTTW notes the origin stories are debated.

Sources: Culinary Historians of Chicago: The socio-culinary history of Chicago's Italian beef (2022); WTTW: Who sold the first Italian beef? (2024)

St. Louis, Missouri (The Hill)

Toasted ravioli

Small meat- or cheese-filled ravioli, breaded and deep-fried, dusted with grated cheese and dipped in marinara.

Restaurants on The Hill, St. Louis's Italian neighborhood, usually get the credit, often with a story about ravioli dropped into the fryer by accident. Food historian Robert Moss, writing for Epicurious, questions that tale, so the first kitchen is uncertain.

Sources: Epicurious: Everything you've heard about toasted ravioli is wrong (2023); The New York Times: Toasted ravioli, the secret of St. Louis (1987)

St. Louis-style pizza

Cracker-thin crust, oregano-seasoned sauce, Provel cheese and toppings to the edge, cut in squares.

Imo's Pizza, opened in 1964, calls itself the originator and made the style common across the city; it describes Provel as a blend of cheddar, Swiss and provolone. Feast Magazine's history covers earlier St. Louis pizzerias, so "first" is Imo's own claim.

Sources: Imo's Pizza: What is St. Louis-style pizza; Imo's Pizza: Our history; Feast Magazine: The history of St. Louis-style pizza (2017)

New Orleans, Louisiana (French Quarter)

Muffuletta

A round sesame loaf layered with Italian cold cuts, provolone and olive salad.

Sicilian immigrants settled near the French Market in an area called "Little Palermo." Salvatore Lupo of Central Grocery, founded in 1906, is widely credited with the first sandwich; the name came from the muffuletto bread.

Sources: 64 Parishes: Muffuletta sandwich; New Orleans Historical: Muffaletta sandwich; Central Grocery: Home of the original muffuletta

San Francisco, California (Fisherman's Wharf)

Cioppino

A tomato-and-wine seafood stew of crab, clams, shrimp and fish, served with bread for the broth.

Italian immigrant fishermen made it on the wharf from the day's catch. The name is debated: a favorite story says it comes from fishermen calling "chip in," while others tie it to ciuppin, a Ligurian fish soup.

Sources: KQED: The fishy origins of cioppino; Fisherman's Wharf: Cioppino's Italian history

Questions

What Italian-American dishes are only found in one city?
Utica greens (Utica, NY), Chicken French (Rochester, NY), the Italian hot dog (Newark, NJ), Trenton tomato pie, Philadelphia's roast pork sandwich, New Haven apizza, Rhode Island pizza strips, Chicago Italian beef, toasted ravioli and St. Louis-style pizza, the New Orleans muffuletta and San Francisco cioppino are all strongly tied to one place.
Are these dishes eaten in Italy?
Not in these forms. They were built by Italian immigrants and their families in American cities, from Italian ingredients and habits plus what was available locally. That's why each one has a city on the map.
Who invented them?
Usually nobody can say for sure. Most origin stories come from one restaurant's or one family's account, and several dishes have more than one claimant. Each stop says whose account it is and links to the sources.

Keep exploring

The big-city scenes are in Italian-American food by city. For how the cuisine took shape, read the Italian-American story and Italian-American vs. Italian food.

Know a dish that belongs on this map? Tell Larry through the contact page. It goes on only with a source.

Share or cite this map

Free to quote with credit and a link back to this page.

Citation

“Only in America: A Map of Regional Italian-American Dishes” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/italian-food/italian-american-dishes-map

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://unclelarryadventures.com/italian-food/italian-american-dishes-map">Only in America: a map of regional Italian-American dishes</a>

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.