City guide · New York

Italian Restaurants in New York

Last updated

The red-sauce institutions, the hard tables and the pizza worth the line — with the same facts for every one: where it is, when it opened, who runs it, how the reservations actually work and what it's known for. Every fact links to its source. Research, not reviews: Larry rates a place only after he's eaten there.

RestaurantNeighborhoodStyleFoundedBookingPriceKnown for
CarboneGreenwich VillageRed-sauce classic2013Resy$$$$Spicy rigatoni vodka, Caesar salad made tableside
Rao'sEast HarlemRed-sauce classic1896Other—Uncle Vincent's lemon chicken, Marinara sauce
Don AngieWest VillageModern Italian-American2017OpenTable—Lasagna for two with Italian sausage Bolognese, Buffalo milk caramelle
Via CarotaWest VillageRegional Italian—Resy—Insalata verde, Grilled octopus
I SodiWest VillageRegional Italian2008Resy—Layered lasagna, Pappardelle al limone
L'ArtusiWest VillageModern Italian2008Resy—Garganelli with mushroom ragù, Roasted mushrooms with pancetta and a fried egg
LiliaWilliamsburgModern Italian2016Resy—Mafaldini with pink peppercorn and Parmigiano, Sheep's milk cheese agnolotti with saffron and honey
TorrisiNolitaModern Italian-American—Resy—Dover sole Francese, Cavatelli with Jamaican beef patty ragù
LucaliCarroll GardensPizzeria—Walk-in only—Large pie with basil, Calzone
RubirosaNolitaPizzeria—Resy—Tie-dye pizza (vodka sauce, tomato and pesto), Classic pizza

Oldest first

  1. 1896 — Rao's, East Harlem
  2. 2008 — I Sodi, West Village
  3. 2008 — L'Artusi, West Village
  4. 2013 — Carbone, Greenwich Village
  5. 2016 — Lilia, Williamsburg
  6. 2017 — Don Angie, West Village

Founding years as stated by each restaurant or the cited source. Places without a confirmed year are left off. "Oldest" claims are often disputed.

No reservation? Start here

  • Carbone →

    The Infatuation reports that people refresh the reservation page at 10am, and that weekday lunch or a very late table is the most realistic way in.

  • Via Carota →

    The restaurant says walk-ins are always welcome.

  • I Sodi →

    The restaurant says walk-ins are always welcome.

  • L'Artusi →

    Some bar and counter seats are kept for walk-ins, first come, first served.

  • Torrisi →

    The bar counter takes walk-ins, first come, first served.

  • Lucali →

    No reservations. First come, first served; names go on the waitlist starting at 4pm.

  • Rubirosa →

    Space is held for walk-ins every day; ask the hosts for open times.

Italian restaurants in San Francisco · Italian restaurants in Boston · Italian restaurants in Los Angeles · Italian restaurants in San Diego · Italian restaurants in Chicago · Italian restaurants in Philadelphia · Italian restaurants in New Haven · Italian restaurants in Providence · Larry's full list of Italian restaurants · best sausage and peppers in New York. 90 US guides so far.

First time at a red-sauce place? What to order at an Italian-American restaurant.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.