City guide · New Haven

Italian Restaurants in New Haven

Last updated

Wooster Street, in the Wooster Square neighborhood, is where New Haven's apizza story is usually told: Frank Pepe (1925) and Sally's (1938) sit blocks apart, Modern Apizza (1934) is up State Street in East Rock, and Zuppardi's has been on Union Avenue in West Haven since 1934. Expect thin, charred pies baked in very hot ovens, with the white clam pie as the order people argue about. This guide covers the apizza legends plus the red-sauce rooms and newer Italian kitchens that round out the city. Research, not reviews: Larry rates a place only after he's eaten there.

How to use this guide

The big Wooster Street pizzerias don't take reservations in New Haven, so plan on a line. The sit-down restaurants book on OpenTable. Where a place lists only a phone number, call to ask. Menus and hours change — confirm on the official site.

RestaurantNeighborhoodStyleFoundedBookingPriceKnown for
Frank Pepe Pizzeria NapoletanaWooster SquarePizzeria1925Walk-in only—White Clam Pizza, Original Tomato Pie
Sally's ApizzaWooster SquarePizzeria1938Walk-in only—Tomato Sauce Pie, Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Pie
Modern ApizzaEast RockPizzeria1934Call to ask—Italian Bomb, Clams Casino pizza
Zuppardi's ApizzaWest HavenPizzeria1932Call to ask—The Special (red pie with mozzarella, mushrooms and homemade fennel sausage), Fresh Clam pizza
BARDowntownPizzeria1991Other—Mashed Potato & Bacon pizza, Clam Casino pizza
Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina NapoletanaWooster SquarePizzeria2019Call to ask—Margherita Verace, Genovese pizza
Roseland ApizzaDerbyPizzeria1935Call to ask—Classic red apizza with tomato sauce and grated cheese, Sausage pie
Tre Scalini RistoranteWooster SquareRed-sauce classic1994OpenTable—Pappardelle al Telefono, Osso Bucco
Consiglio's RestaurantWooster SquareRed-sauce classic1938OpenTable—Homemade Cavatelli with Braciole, Nonna's Meatballs
Caffe BravoEast RockModern Italian1994OpenTable—Bucatini Cacio e Pepe, Spaghetti alle Vongole

Wooster Street and New Haven apizza

A few facts from the restaurants' own histories, so the legend has dates attached.

  • Frank and Filomena Pepe opened their pizzeria at 163 Wooster Street in June 1925, then moved next door to 157 Wooster Street in 1936. source
  • Sally's says Filomena Consiglio bought a Wooster Street restaurant with a bread oven in 1938 and had her son Sally run it as a pizzeria. source
  • Sally's describes New Haven-style apizza as handmade, coal-fired, sauce-forward and charred, not burnt — pronounced “ah-beetz.” source
  • Not every legend still burns coal: Modern Apizza says it converted its oven to oil after coke production ended in New Haven by 1967. source
  • Zuppardi's began as Salerno's Bakery in New Haven in 1932 and moved to Union Avenue in West Haven in 1934. source

Want a red pie at home tonight? Start with Larry's pizza margherita.

Oldest first

  1. 1925 — Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, Wooster Square
  2. 1932 — Zuppardi's Apizza, West Haven
  3. 1934 — Modern Apizza, East Rock
  4. 1935 — Roseland Apizza, Derby
  5. 1938 — Sally's Apizza, Wooster Square
  6. 1938 — Consiglio's Restaurant, Wooster Square
  7. 1991 — BAR, Downtown
  8. 1994 — Tre Scalini Ristorante, Wooster Square
  9. 1994 — Caffe Bravo, East Rock
  10. 2019 — Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina Napoletana, Wooster Square

Founding years as stated by each restaurant or the cited source. Places without a confirmed year are left off. "Oldest" claims are often disputed.

No reservation? Start here

  • Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana →

    The New Haven location is walk-in only, seated first come, first served. Phone (203) 865-5762.

  • Sally's Apizza →

    Sally's takes reservations only at its newer locations; New Haven stays first come, first served for dine-in. Phone (203) 624-5271.

  • BAR →

    BAR doesn't take reservations for parties of fewer than 8; walk in.

More New Haven on the site

Questions

Do Frank Pepe's and Sally's take reservations in New Haven?
No. Pepe's New Haven location is walk-in only, first come, first served. Sally's takes reservations only at its newer locations; New Haven stays first come, first served for dine-in.
Which New Haven Italian restaurants book on OpenTable?
Tre Scalini, Consiglio's and Caffe Bravo all book through OpenTable.
Can a big group book a table at BAR?
Yes. Parties of 8 to 13 book on Resy or by phone, and 14 or more use the event form on BAR's reservations page. Smaller groups just walk in.
Is all New Haven apizza coal-fired?
No. Pepe's and Sally's still talk about coal-fired ovens, but Modern Apizza says it switched its oven to oil after coke production ended in New Haven by 1967.
Has Larry rated these restaurants?
Not yet. These pages are research, and every fact links to its source. Larry adds a pepper rating only after he has actually eaten somewhere.

Italian restaurants in New York · Italian restaurants in San Francisco · Italian restaurants in Boston · Italian restaurants in Los Angeles · Italian restaurants in San Diego · Italian restaurants in Chicago · Italian restaurants in Philadelphia · Italian restaurants in Providence · Larry's full list of Italian restaurants. 90 US guides so far.

First time at a red-sauce place? What to order at an Italian-American restaurant.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.