What to Order at an Italian-American Restaurant

Last updated

Short answer

Share an antipasto, then order one pasta and one main for the table, or a pasta as your main. Ask for the pasta al dente: cooked through but still firm when you bite it. The simple dishes tell you the most about a kitchen: the marinara, the meatball and the chicken or eggplant parm. Ask what's made in-house and what the special is.

This is the guide for the red-sauce dining room down the street, not a restaurant in Rome. If you're traveling to Italy, the menu and the manners work differently, and we have a separate guide for that.

How the menu is laid out

Most Italian-American menus run the same way. Appetizers (antipasti) come first: fried calamari, baked clams, mozzarella, a cold antipasto plate. Then soups and salads. Then the pasta section. Then the entrées: chicken, veal and seafood, often with a separate list of "parm" dishes. Desserts are cannoli, tiramisu and spumoni.

Portions are usually big. Plenty of tables share an appetizer, then split a pasta and a main. Many places will do a half order of pasta if you ask, but not all, so ask. Entrées often come with a side of pasta, which is an American habit: in Italy, pasta is its own course.

How we got the red-sauce menu

Food historian Paul Freedman, writing in Bon Appétit, traces the style to the 1880s and later, when Southern Italian immigrants opened restaurants in American cities. Cooks there made dishes that weren't known back home. Meat was cheaper in America, so meatballs went on spaghetti, and Parmesan, once a treat, went on eggplant, chicken and veal.

Freedman names Dante & Luigi's in Philadelphia among those early restaurants. It's still open, and it's in our Philadelphia guide. So the menu you're reading is its own cuisine, Italian-American, with its own classics. Ordering chicken parm isn't a mistake. It's ordering the house specialty.

What "al dente" actually gets you

Al dente is Italian for "to the tooth." Barilla's explanation, as reported by Simply Recipes: the pasta is tender but firm when you bite it, and it holds its shape under a heavy sauce. If you can see a white line in the middle, it's undercooked.

Why ask for it? Firm pasta keeps cooking a little on the hot plate and in the sauce on its way to you, and it doesn't go soft in a creamy or meat sauce. Many American kitchens cook pasta softer by default, so it's fine to say "al dente, please." Baked pastas like ziti and lasagna are different: they're meant to be soft.

The dishes that tell you about the kitchen

These are Larry's tells, not rules. A plain marinara, or spaghetti with tomato sauce, has nowhere to hide: you'll taste whether the sauce was cooked with care or poured from a big tub.

The meatball says the same thing about the meat and the hands that rolled it. Tender, seasoned all the way through, not a dense ball. Chicken or eggplant parm shows whether the kitchen fries to order: the coating should still have some crunch under the sauce and cheese. La Cucina Italiana says rubbery, over-sauced versions are "more the rule than the exception," so a good one is a good sign.

If clams are on the menu, linguine with clam sauce made with clams in the shell tells you the kitchen buys fresh seafood. And look at the specials board: a kitchen that cooks with the season usually writes it down.

Ordering like a regular

Ask what's made in-house: the pasta, the mozzarella, the cannoli filling. Ask what the special is and what the server would eat. Order a few appetizers for the table instead of one each. Don't fill up on the bread before the pasta lands. And ask for the cannoli to be filled to order if the place does that, because crisp shells are the whole point.

In the US, the usual American tipping rules apply. Italy is different: see our guides to tipping and the coperto (cover charge) before you travel.

Sources and evidence

Common questions

What's the best thing to order at an Italian restaurant?
Order what the restaurant is known for, and ask about the specials. If you want to judge the kitchen, try a simple dish: the marinara, the meatballs or a parm. Simple dishes have nowhere to hide.
What does al dente mean?
Al dente is Italian for "to the tooth." The pasta is cooked through but still firm when you bite it, and it holds its shape in the sauce. A white line in the middle means it's undercooked.
Is chicken parm a real Italian dish?
It's a real Italian-American dish. Historian Paul Freedman notes that Parmesan went onto eggplant, chicken and veal in American Italian restaurants. Eggplant parmigiana is the older southern Italian dish behind it.
Can I order pasta as a main course?
Yes. At Italian-American restaurants, a plate of pasta is a normal main. Many places also offer half orders, so ask if you want pasta and an entrée.
Do you tip at an Italian-American restaurant?
Yes, in the US the usual American tipping customs apply. Tipping in Italy works differently, and there may be a cover charge (coperto) on the bill.

Make it

More straight answers

Share or cite this guide

Free to quote with credit and a link back to this page.

Citation

“What to Order at an Italian-American Restaurant” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/what-to-order-at-an-italian-american-restaurant

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/what-to-order-at-an-italian-american-restaurant">What to Order at an Italian-American Restaurant</a>

Page URL

https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/what-to-order-at-an-italian-american-restaurant

Next up

Keep going — a recipe to try, a film to watch, and an answer to the question you were about to search.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.