No. 80 · Carroll Gardens, New York · Pizzeria

Lucali

Last updated

Last verified:

Quick answer

Lucali is a pizzeria in Carroll Gardens, New York. It takes no reservations. It's known for Large pie with basil, Calzone.

Neighborhood
Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Style
Pizzeria
Founded
Not confirmed
Chef / family
Pizzaiolo Mark Iaconosource
Known for
Large pie with basil, Calzone
Address
575 Henry Street, New York, NY 11231source
Hours
Mon - 5:00 pm - 10:00 pm, Tue - Closed, Wed - 5:00 pm - 10:00 pmsource

How to get a table

  • No reservations

    No reservations. First come, first served; names go on the waitlist starting at 4pm.source

  • Walk-ins and the bar

    Waitlist names are taken from 4pm. It's cash only and BYOB.source

Larry's playbook: Be there before 4pm to get your name down, bring cash and your own bottle, and get a drink nearby while you wait.

The story

  • Mark Iacono opened Lucali to save the candy store he grew up with in Carroll Gardens.source

Larry's verdict

"Candlelit, cash-only, line up early."

An in-character note from Larry's list, not a review. Larry hasn't rated Lucali yet — the pepper rating appears only after he's actually eaten there.

Make it at home

Our own home recipes in the same style, not the restaurant's recipe.

Good for

  • Walk-ins
  • Date night

Editorial suggestions from the booking rules and menu, not a visit report.

If you can't get in

Or stay in: Pizza Margherita.

Questions people ask

Do you need a reservation at Lucali?
Lucali doesn't take reservations. No reservations. First come, first served; names go on the waitlist starting at 4pm. Waitlist names are taken from 4pm. It's cash only and BYOB.
What is Lucali famous for?
Large pie with basil, Calzone. Mark Iacono opened Lucali to save the candy store he grew up with in Carroll Gardens.
What should you order at Lucali?
Start with what it's known for: Large pie with basil, Calzone.
Where is Lucali?
575 Henry Street, Carroll Gardens, New York, NY 11231.
Where can I go if I can't get into Lucali?
Try Rubirosa in Nolita or Carbone in Greenwich Village, or cook it at home.

Map

Lucali575 Henry Street, New York, NY 11231, USA

The map loads from Google Maps when you tap.

Pin placed from the address above. Open in Google Maps

Sources

Facts checked against these sources on 2026-10-24. Hours, prices and booking rules change — confirm on the official site before you go.

All New York Italian restaurant guides →

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.