City guide · New York
Best Sausage and Peppers in New York
Compiled from public sources. These are neighborhoods, markets, feasts and food areas worth seeking out, not reviews or rankings of specific restaurants. Larry's notes are tongue-in-cheek. Hours and details change, so confirm before you go.
Where is the best sausage and peppers in New York?
The best sausage and peppers in New York City is served at the Feast of San Gennaro on Mulberry Street each September, with Faicco's on Bleecker Street and the Arthur Avenue Retail Market in the Bronx as the year-round standbys.
| City | New York City, New York, USA |
|---|---|
| Ask for it as | Sausage and peppers |
| Pilgrimage entries here | 7 |
| Best time to go | Mid-September, during the Feast of San Gennaro. Second-best is any Italian-American street feast in the outer boroughs from June through September. |
| Local rule | Butcher-shop sausage beats supermarket sausage everywhere, but in New York the gap is enormous. If the stand grinds its own, the fennel actually tastes like fennel. |
New York is where sausage and peppers stopped being a home dish and became street food. The Feast of San Gennaro has run on Mulberry Street since 1926, and for eleven days in September the whole neighbourhood smells like fennel, charred onion and griddle smoke.
The rest of the year the dish lives in butcher shops and markets rather than restaurants. Faicco's in the West Village grinds its own; Arthur Avenue in the Bronx is the more serious, less photographed version of Little Italy.
New York on Larry’s Pilgrimage List — Top 100
| List no. | Where | Order this | Larry’s note |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Feast of San Gennaro — Mulberry StreetArea: city-level location | Sausage, peppers and onions on a roll | The cathedral. Eleven days a year, the whole street smells like this dish. |
| #2 | Faicco's Italian SpecialtiesArea: city-level location | Sweet sausage hero | Butcher-shop sausage means the fennel actually tastes like fennel. |
| #7 | Arthur Avenue Retail MarketArea: city-level location | Hot sausage with roasted red peppers | The real Little Italy, and everyone in the Bronx knows it. |
| #8 | Ferrara-side Mott Street countersArea: city-level location | Sausage plate, extra onions | Eat standing up. Sitting down is for tourists. |
| #21 | Belmont Avenue butchersArea: city-level location | House-made sweet sausage | Ask for the fennel-heavy batch. |
| #22 | Court Street pork storesArea: city-level location | Sausage and peppers by the pound | Sunday tray. Feeds nine, or Larry. |
| #23 | Staten Island pork storesArea: city-level location | Sausage, peppers, onions hero | The most underrated borough for this dish. |
How to order it in New York
- Sausage, peppers and onions on a hero roll — not a plate. In New York this is a walking dish.
- Sweet sausage if the peppers are the point; hot if you want the sausage loud. Half-and-half is a normal order at feast stands.
- Ask for extra onions. They cost nothing and they are what keeps the roll from going dry.
The local rule: Butcher-shop sausage beats supermarket sausage everywhere, but in New York the gap is enormous. If the stand grinds its own, the fennel actually tastes like fennel.
Best time to go: Mid-September, during the Feast of San Gennaro. Second-best is any Italian-American street feast in the outer boroughs from June through September.
Questions people ask about New York
Where is the best sausage and peppers in NYC?
The Feast of San Gennaro on Mulberry Street in September is the classic. Year-round, Faicco's Italian Specialties on Bleecker Street and the Arthur Avenue Retail Market in the Bronx are the two Larry sends people to.
When is the Feast of San Gennaro?
Eleven days each September on Mulberry Street in Little Italy. Dates shift slightly year to year, so check before you travel.
Is sausage and peppers a New York dish?
It is Italian-American, and New York's street feasts made it famous. The pairing itself comes out of southern Italian home cooking.
Make it at home instead
You do not need a plane ticket. Larry’s own version takes about forty minutes in a cast-iron pan.
Sausage and peppers in other cities
Elsewhere in USA
Further afield
Join the crew
Join Larry’s email list for future recipes and updates. Newsletter sending has not started yet.
Your address is kept privately. Contact Larry to request removal from the list.