No. 84 · Wooster Square, New Haven · Pizzeria

Sally's Apizza

Last updated

Last verified:

Quick answer

Sally's Apizza is a pizzeria in Wooster Square, New Haven, open since 1938. It takes no reservations. It's known for Tomato Sauce Pie, Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Pie, Potato & Rosemary pie.

Neighborhood
Wooster Square
Style
Pizzeria
Founded
1938source
Chef / family
Founded by Salvatore “Sally” Consiglio.source
Known for
Tomato Sauce Pie, Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Pie, Potato & Rosemary pie, New Haven Original Clam pie
Address
237 Wooster Street, New Haven, CT 06511source
Hours
Sunday 10:30am–9pm; Monday–Thursday 11am–9pm; Friday–Saturday 10:30am–10pm.source

How to get a table

  • No reservations

    Sally's takes reservations only at its newer locations; New Haven stays first come, first served for dine-in. Phone (203) 624-5271.source

Larry's playbook: Walk up and wait your turn — the New Haven room doesn't book tables, even though Sally's newer locations do.

The story

  • Salvatore “Sally” Consiglio was born in New Haven in 1915.source
  • In 1938 his mother, Filomena, bought a Wooster Street restaurant with a bread oven and had him run it as a pizzeria.source
  • Sally's describes New Haven-style apizza as handmade, coal-fired and sauce-forward — charred, not burnt — and says it's pronounced “ah-beetz.”source

Larry's verdict

"The other side of the New Haven argument."

An in-character note from Larry's list, not a review. Larry hasn't rated Sally's Apizza yet — the pepper rating appears only after he's actually eaten there.

Make it at home

Our own home recipes in the same style, not the restaurant's recipe.

Good for

  • Families
  • Groups

Editorial suggestions from the booking rules and menu, not a visit report.

If you can't get in

Or stay in: Pizza Margherita.

Questions people ask

Do you need a reservation at Sally's Apizza?
Sally's Apizza doesn't take reservations. Sally's takes reservations only at its newer locations; New Haven stays first come, first served for dine-in. Phone (203) 624-5271.
What is Sally's Apizza famous for?
Tomato Sauce Pie, Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Pie, Potato & Rosemary pie, New Haven Original Clam pie. Salvatore “Sally” Consiglio was born in New Haven in 1915.
What should you order at Sally's Apizza?
Start with what it's known for: Tomato Sauce Pie, Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Pie, Potato & Rosemary pie.
Where is Sally's Apizza?
237 Wooster Street, Wooster Square, New Haven, CT 06511.
Where can I go if I can't get into Sally's Apizza?
Try Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana in Wooster Square or Modern Apizza in East Rock, or cook it at home.

Map

Sally's Apizza237 Wooster Street, New Haven, CT 06511, USA

The map loads from Google Maps when you tap.

Pin placed from the address above. Open in Google Maps

Sources

Facts checked against these sources on 2026-11-03. Hours, prices and booking rules change — confirm on the official site before you go.

All New Haven Italian restaurant guides →

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.