East Rock, New Haven · Pizzeria

Modern Apizza

Last updated

Last verified:

Quick answer

Modern Apizza is a pizzeria in East Rock, New Haven, open since 1934. Its reservation policy isn't stated online, so call ahead. It's known for Italian Bomb, Clams Casino pizza, Clam pizza.

Neighborhood
East Rock
Style
Pizzeria
Founded
1934source
Chef / family
Opened by Antonio “Tony” Tolli as Tony's Apizza; later run by Louis Persano and then Nick Nuzzo.source
Known for
Italian Bomb, Clams Casino pizza, Clam pizza
Address
874 State Street, New Haven, CT 06511source
Hours
Closed Monday; Tuesday–Saturday 10:30am–10pm; Sunday 3–10pm.source

How to get a table

  • Reservations: not stated online

    The official site lists 203-776-5306. Call to ask before you plan around a table.source

Larry's playbook: It's closed Mondays. Call ahead if you need a table held, since the site doesn't say whether it takes reservations.

The story

  • Tony Tolli opened Tony's Apizza at 874 State Street in 1934, with a coke-fired brick oven built only for pizza.source
  • Louis Persano, who had trained with Frank Pepe, took over the lease in 1944; a neighboring pharmacist suggested the name “Modern” for the new owner.source
  • Nick Nuzzo started there at 14 in 1937 and bought the business in 1952.source
  • When coke production ended in New Haven by 1967, Modern converted its oven to oil rather than switching to coal or gas.source

Larry's verdict

Larry hasn't rated Modern Apizza yet — the pepper rating appears only after he's actually eaten there.

Good for

  • Families
  • Groups

Editorial suggestions from the booking rules and menu, not a visit report.

If you can't get in

Questions people ask

Do you need a reservation at Modern Apizza?
Modern Apizza doesn't state a reservation policy online. The official site lists 203-776-5306. Call to ask before you plan around a table.
What is Modern Apizza famous for?
Italian Bomb, Clams Casino pizza, Clam pizza. Tony Tolli opened Tony's Apizza at 874 State Street in 1934, with a coke-fired brick oven built only for pizza.
What should you order at Modern Apizza?
Start with what it's known for: Italian Bomb, Clams Casino pizza, Clam pizza.
Where is Modern Apizza?
874 State Street, East Rock, New Haven, CT 06511.
Where can I go if I can't get into Modern Apizza?
Try Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana in Wooster Square or Sally's Apizza in Wooster Square, or cook it at home.

Map

Modern Apizza874 State Street, New Haven, CT 06511, USA

The map loads from Google Maps when you tap.

Pin placed from the address above. Open in Google Maps

Sources

Facts checked against these sources on 2026-11-03. Hours, prices and booking rules change — confirm on the official site before you go.

All New Haven Italian restaurant guides →

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.