Italian Salads and Dressings

Last updated

Short answer

In Italy salad is usually dressed at the table, not with a bottled dressing: salt first, then a little red wine vinegar or lemon juice, then plenty of extra-virgin olive oil, tossed right before eating. "Italian dressing" in a bottle is an American creation. Classic Italian salads include insalata caprese, panzanella, arugula with Parmigiano, fennel and orange, bean salad and insalata di mare.

Oil, vinegar, salt. That's the Italian salad dressing, and it lives on the table, not in a bottle with a picture of Italy on it. Here are the salads, the dressings, and which one goes with what.

The salads and dressings

How Italians dress a salad

In Italy, salad is normally dressed at the table with olive oil, vinegar or lemon juice and salt, sometimes balsamic, rather than a premixed vinaigrette.

An old proverb gives the method: "A ben condire l'insalata ci vuole un avaro per l'aceto, un giusto per il sale e uno strambo per l'olio." To dress a salad well you need a miser for the vinegar, a fair person for the salt and an eccentric for the oil. Regional versions add a madman to toss it.

So: a careful pinch of salt, a stingy splash of vinegar, a generous pour of oil, and a good toss. Salt goes in before the oil because it dissolves in the vinegar, not in the oil.

Is Italian dressing from Italy?

No. Bottled Italian dressing is American, and it isn't used in Italy. Two restaurants are usually credited: Ken's Steak House in Framingham, Massachusetts, where Florence Hanna's house dressing is said to date to 1941, and the Wishbone restaurant in Kansas City, where Phillip Sollomi served an Italian vinaigrette from 1948.

Both families were Italian-American, so it's a fair Italian-American invention. Larry's homemade version uses olive oil, red wine vinegar, garlic and oregano.

Citronette, vinaigrette and balsamic

Citronette is olive oil emulsified with lemon juice and salt. The name comes from the French citron; a vinaigrette is the same idea with vinegar.

Larry's recipes use about 3 parts oil to 1 part vinegar for the Italian dressing and 2 parts oil to 1 part lemon for the citronette. Lemon goes with greens, fennel, beans and seafood; red wine vinegar with sturdy leaves and tomatoes; balsamic with mixed greens, tomatoes and grilled vegetables.

For balsamic, use everyday Balsamic Vinegar of Modena in dressing. The aged traditional kind is for a few drops, not a jar.

Which dressing for which salad

Arugula and Parmesan: lemon and oil. The recipe already has it built in.

Caprese: olive oil and salt only. Good tomatoes don't need vinegar.

Panzanella: red wine vinegar and oil, soaked into the bread.

Fennel and orange: oil and salt; the orange brings the acid.

Bean salad and seafood salad: lemon and oil, and both can be dressed ahead.

Iceberg, chopped or sub-shop salads: the Italian-American dressings, homemade Italian or the copycat-style house dressing.

Sources and evidence

Common questions

What is the most popular Italian salad?
Insalata caprese, tomato and mozzarella with basil and olive oil, is the best known. Panzanella, arugula with Parmigiano and mixed green salads are everyday favorites too.
What dressing do Italians use on salad?
Usually just extra-virgin olive oil, vinegar or lemon juice and salt, added at the table. Bottled dressings aren't the Italian habit.
Is Italian dressing actually Italian?
No. It's an American dressing, usually traced to Italian-American restaurant families in Massachusetts and Kansas City in the 1940s. It isn't used in Italy.
What is the ratio of oil to vinegar?
A common starting point is 3 parts oil to 1 part vinegar. Larry's lemon dressing uses 2 to 1 because lemon is milder than vinegar.
When do Italians eat salad?
Often with or after the main course, as a contorno or a fresh finish. Italian-American dinners often serve it first.
Can I dress salad ahead of time?
Not leafy salads; dress them right before eating. Bean salads, seafood salad and panzanella are made to sit in their dressing.

Make it

More straight answers

Share or cite this guide

Free to quote with credit and a link back to this page.

Citation

“Italian Salads and Dressings” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/italian-salads-and-dressings

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/italian-salads-and-dressings">Italian Salads and Dressings</a>

Page URL

https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/italian-salads-and-dressings

Next up

Keep going — a recipe to try, a film to watch, and an answer to the question you were about to search.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.