Italian-American Dishes Invented in America

Last updated

Short answer

Chicken parmesan, spaghetti and meatballs, the muffuletta, cioppino, shrimp scampi as Americans know it, the Italian sub and sausage-and-pepper sandwiches all grew up in Italian-American communities. Most have Italian roots, like eggplant parmigiana or polpette, but took their familiar form in the United States, often with no single documented inventor.

Ask for chicken parm in Naples and you'll get a polite look. That isn't a knock on the dish. It's proof that Italian Americans invented a cuisine of their own, and it deserves its own history.

Cook the American originals

Chicken parmesan

The parmigiana idea came from southern Italy, where it mostly meant eggplant. La Cucina Italiana suggests the chicken version may trace to breaded veal cotoletta, and that it caught on in the postwar years as chicken became a bigger part of the American diet. How exactly it evolved is still debated.

Spaghetti and meatballs

Italy has polpette and small meatballs in some pastas, but the big-meatball plate is American. Smithsonian Magazine connects it to immigrants finding meat more affordable here.

The muffuletta

New Orleans Historical credits Salvatore Lupo of Central Grocery, widely, with making the first muffuletta sandwich in 1906, using the round Sicilian loaf of the same name. No such sandwich exists in Italy.

Cioppino, scampi and the sub

Cioppino is linked to the Italian fishing community of San Francisco. Shrimp scampi, in its garlic-butter American form, and the Italian sub or hoagie grew up in Italian-American restaurants and delis. Exact origins and inventors for these aren't documented, and we don't pretend otherwise.

And ours

Sausage and peppers, Sunday gravy and Chicken Murphy belong on this list too. Our history pages for each separate the documented trail from the family legend.

Sources and evidence

Common questions

Is chicken parmesan Italian?
It's Italian-American. Italy has eggplant parmigiana; the chicken version took its familiar form in the US.
Who invented the muffuletta?
Salvatore Lupo of Central Grocery in New Orleans is widely credited with the first one, in 1906.
Is fettuccine Alfredo American?
No. It started in Rome, at Alfredo di Lelio's restaurant, but became famous in America; the cream-heavy version is the Italian-American take.

Make it

More straight answers

Cite this guide: “Italian-American Dishes Invented in America” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/italian-american-dishes-invented-in-america

Next up

Keep going — a recipe to try, a film to watch, and an answer to the question you were about to search.

Wear it / Get it

Sausage and Peppers AS Colour Relaxed Hoodie

Fourthwall

Sausage and Peppers AS Colour Relaxed Hoodie

The sausage-and-peppers crowd has a uniform. This is one option.

$58.00 USD · listed price; may have changed, confirm on Fourthwall

View on Fourthwall

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.