Italian Christmas Cookies, Ranked by Larry

Last updated

Short answer

Larry's top five: cuccidati, rainbow cookies, pignoli, struffoli and pizzelle, followed by ricotta cookies, wedding cookies, cantucci, almond biscotti and torrone. It's his personal, in-character ranking, not a survey, and every one has a full recipe on the site.

Every Italian-American family has a cookie tray, and every family thinks theirs is the right one. This is Larry's. He ranked ten Christmas sweets that already have recipes on this site, and he'll argue about the order with anybody. Number ten isn't even a cookie. He knows. If you just want to plan and bake a tray, the full Italian Christmas cookie guide has the baking order and storage.

Larry's ranking

How Larry ranked them

Three questions. Does it say Christmas, or could it show up any time of year? Does it vanish from the tray, or is it still there on New Year's? And is it worth the work? Cuccidati win on all three. Biscotti lose on the first one, because Larry eats them in July too.

That's opinion, for fun. There's no survey behind it, and no single cookie list that every Italian or Italian-American family shares. Regions, towns and families all have their own.

Plan and bake the whole tray: baking order and storage →

Build your own top three

Larry's advice for a tray people remember: one soft, one chewy, one crunchy. Ricotta cookies for soft, pignoli for chewy, cantucci or pizzelle for crunch. Add rainbow cookies if you have two days, and struffoli if you have a platter to spare.

Bake each recipe on its own and cool everything completely before packing. Keep crisp cookies in a separate tin from soft or glazed ones, and follow each recipe's own storage notes.

Common questions

What is the most popular Italian Christmas cookie?
There's no single answer: favorites vary by region and by family. Larry's own number one is cuccidati, the Sicilian fig cookie, and rainbow cookies are the Italian-American bakery classic.
Is this ranking based on a survey?
No. It's Larry's personal, in-character opinion. Every cookie on it has a full recipe on the site, so you can bake them and make your own list.
Which Italian Christmas cookies can I make ahead?
Crisp ones like cantucci, biscotti and pizzelle keep well in tins, and the cuccidati filling can be made ahead. Rainbow cookies need two days because they press overnight. Check each recipe's storage notes.
Why is torrone on a cookie list?
Because it's on the Christmas tray every year. Torrone is honey-almond nougat, a candy rather than a cookie, and Larry ranked it tenth for exactly that reason.

Make it

More straight answers

Share or cite this guide

Free to quote with credit and a link back to this page.

Citation

“Italian Christmas Cookies, Ranked by Larry” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/best-italian-christmas-cookies-ranked

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/best-italian-christmas-cookies-ranked">Italian Christmas Cookies, Ranked by Larry</a>

Page URL

https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/best-italian-christmas-cookies-ranked

Next up

Keep going — a recipe to try, a film to watch, and an answer to the question you were about to search.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.