Illustrative spinach frittata

Italian Baby Shower: Menu, Drinks and Planning

Last updated

A make-ahead Italian brunch for the parents-to-be, pregnancy-friendly

A baby shower is a daytime party: think brunch or a long lunch, with things you can make the day before. The guest of honor is pregnant, so the menu leans on cooked dishes, pasteurized cheeses and good zero-proof drinks.

Customs differ by family. Some showers are for women only, some are for everyone; some open gifts, some don't. Ask the parents-to-be, or whoever knows them best, before you plan.

The recipes

Every dish links to a recipe already on the site, chosen because it can be made ahead and suits a pregnant guest of honor as written or with the swap noted.

The menu

Savory: a spinach frittata cut into squares, insalata caprese with pasteurized mozzarella, bruschetta, focaccia, an arugula and Parmesan salad, and a tray of baked stuffed shells for a bigger crowd. Sweet: cannoli, pizzelle, Italian wedding cookies (they're just as good at a shower) and panna cotta made the day before.

Pregnancy-friendly swaps

The CDC lists unheated deli meat, cold cuts and dry or fermented sausages as riskier for pregnant people and says to heat them to 165°F or until steaming. So skip the prosciutto and salami board, or put the cured meats into something hot. Choose cheeses made with pasteurized milk; hard cheeses like Parmesan and pasteurized mozzarella are on the CDC's safer list.

Classic tiramisù uses raw egg yolks and often rum, so it's off this menu. Panna cotta is the make-ahead dessert instead.

The CDC says there is no known safe amount of alcohol during pregnancy. Make the drink bar zero-proof first: sparkling water with citrus, Crodino or another non-alcoholic aperitivo, and Italian sodas. Guests who want Prosecco can have it on the side.

Planning timeline

Four weeks out: agree on the host, guest list and date, and ask about allergies and food restrictions. One week out: bake and freeze the pizzelle and cookies. The day before: make the frittata and panna cotta, assemble the stuffed shells and set the table. The day of: bake the focaccia and shells, assemble the caprese and bruschetta last, and fill the cannoli to order.

Keep cold food at 40°F (4°C) or below and don't leave perishable food out more than two hours, or one hour above 90°F (32°C).

Keep cooking

Sources

Food safety: US safe minimum internal temperatures.

Frequently asked questions

What food should I serve at an Italian baby shower?

A make-ahead brunch: frittata, caprese, bruschetta, focaccia, a baked pasta, and cannoli and cookies for dessert.

Can a pregnant guest eat prosciutto?

The CDC lists unheated cured and deli meats as riskier during pregnancy and advises heating them to 165°F or until steaming hot. Leave them off the cold board.

Is tiramisù safe at a baby shower?

Classic tiramisù uses raw egg yolks and often rum, so we left it off. Panna cotta is a make-ahead swap.

What drinks work for an Italian baby shower?

Zero-proof first: sparkling water with citrus, a non-alcoholic Italian aperitivo like Crodino, or Italian sodas. Offer Prosecco separately for other guests.

How far ahead can I make the food?

Cookies and pizzelle a week or more ahead, frozen. Frittata, panna cotta and the assembled stuffed shells the day before.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.