Illustrative stack of thin golden pizzelle with a snowflake pattern dusted with powdered sugar

The Wedding Cookie Table: Tradition, Planning & What to Bake

Last updated

The Pittsburgh and Youngstown tradition of family-baked cookies, and how to plan your own

In western Pennsylvania and Ohio's Mahoning Valley, around Pittsburgh and Youngstown, many weddings have a cookie table: dozens of kinds of homemade cookies, baked by the family and set out next to the cake. NPR and The New York Times have both covered it.

Where it started is debated. Local historians tie it to Italian and Eastern European immigrant communities, and nobody can name a first table. What everyone agrees on is that the aunts bake for weeks.

The recipes

Every cookie links to a recipe already on the site; anything we don't have a recipe for is named as such.

Where the cookie table comes from

The tradition is strongest in the towns around Pittsburgh and Youngstown, where Italian and Eastern European immigrant families settled side by side. Each family brings its own cookies, so tables often mix Italian pizzelle with Eastern European favorites like nut rolls and kolachi.

Some people say it began as a way for families to contribute when they couldn't afford a big cake. That's a story people tell; we couldn't find a documented first cookie table, so we're not claiming one.

The Italian cookies to bake

Pizzelle, the thin anise or vanilla waffle cookies, are the cookie most people name first. Add Italian wedding cookies (the powdered-sugar snowballs), pignoli cookies, rainbow cookies, cantucci and ricotta cookies, and you have the Italian side of the table covered.

In parts of western Pennsylvania, 'Italian wedding cookie' can also mean a soft anise drop cookie with glaze. If a relative asks for wedding cookies, ask which one they mean.

We don't have recipes yet for the Eastern European favorites like nut rolls, kolachi or ladylocks. If your family has one, it belongs on the table.

How many cookies to plan

There's no official number. As a starting point, we suggest planning about six to eight cookies per guest across all kinds, more if guests take boxes home. Ten to twelve kinds looks generous; more is a family competition.

Split the baking: give each baker one or two kinds and a target count, and keep a shared list so you don't end up with six trays of the same cookie.

Baking schedule and storage

Start four to six weeks out with cookies that freeze well: butter cookies, wedding cookies, pignoli and baked pizzelle all freeze in airtight containers with parchment between layers. Bake cantucci and taralli in the last week or two; they keep at room temperature.

Thaw frozen cookies in their sealed containers so condensation doesn't make them soggy. Glaze or dust with powdered sugar after thawing, not before.

Skip anything with a cream, custard or fresh ricotta filling unless it can stay refrigerated. Cookies sitting out at a reception should be the kind that are safe at room temperature.

Setting up the table

Use tiered stands and platters, one kind per platter, and keep extra trays in the back to refill. Put a small card by each cookie with its name, who baked it and whether it contains nuts. Most Italian cookies do.

Many tables have small boxes or bags so guests can take a few home. Put them at the end of the table, after the platters, so people fill them once.

Ask your venue first. Some venues restrict outside food or charge a fee for it.

Keep cooking

Sources

Food safety: US safe minimum internal temperatures.

Frequently asked questions

What is a wedding cookie table?

A table of homemade cookies, baked by family and friends and served at the reception alongside the cake. It's most common in western Pennsylvania and Ohio's Mahoning Valley, around Pittsburgh and Youngstown.

Where did the wedding cookie table come from?

It's traced to Italian and Eastern European immigrant communities in the region, but the exact origin is debated and no one has documented a first table.

How many cookies do I need for a cookie table?

There's no official rule. As a starting point we suggest about six to eight cookies per guest across all kinds, more if guests take boxes home.

What Italian cookies go on a cookie table?

Pizzelle, Italian wedding cookies, pignoli cookies, rainbow cookies, cantucci and ricotta cookies are common Italian choices.

How far ahead can I bake for a cookie table?

Freezer-friendly cookies like butter cookies, wedding cookies, pignoli and pizzelle can be baked four to six weeks ahead and frozen airtight. Bake dry cookies like cantucci in the last week or two.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.