City guide · Ohio

Best Sausage and Peppers in Cleveland

Compiled from public sources. These are neighborhoods, markets, feasts and food areas worth seeking out, not reviews or rankings of specific restaurants. Larry's notes are tongue-in-cheek. Hours and details change, so confirm before you go.

Where is the best sausage and peppers in Cleveland?

Cleveland's sausage and peppers lives in Little Italy on Murray Hill and at the West Side Market, where the sausage is coarse-ground, heavily fennelled and usually sold by the pound to cook at home.

Key facts about sausage and peppers in Cleveland.
CityCleveland, Ohio, USA
Ask for it asSausage and peppers
Pilgrimage entries here2
Best time to goMid-August, during the Feast of the Assumption on Murray Hill.
Local ruleThis is a buy-it-and-cook-it city more than an order-it-out city. The best version is the one you make from market sausage.

Cleveland's Little Italy grew around the Lakeview Cemetery stonecutters, and Murray Hill still keeps the bakeries and butchers that came with them.

The West Side Market is the other half of the story: a century-old hall where several butchers make their own Italian sausage, and the peppers come from the produce arcade fifty feet away.

Cleveland on Larry’s Pilgrimage List — Top 100

In-character pilgrimage entries in Cleveland, with food ideas and existing list numbers.
List no.WhereOrder thisLarry’s note
#16Little Italy — Murray HillArea: city-level locationSausage and peppers with cannoli chaserFeast of the Assumption weekend is the peak.
#18West Side Market stallsArea: city-level locationHot Italian sausage sandwichSaturday morning, before the crowd.

How to order it in Cleveland

  • A pound of hot and a pound of sweet from a market butcher, cooked at home in cast iron.
  • At the Feast of the Assumption in August, take it on a roll from a street stand.
  • Ask which day the sausage was ground. They will tell you.

The local rule: This is a buy-it-and-cook-it city more than an order-it-out city. The best version is the one you make from market sausage.

Best time to go: Mid-August, during the Feast of the Assumption on Murray Hill.

Questions people ask about Cleveland

Where do you buy Italian sausage in Cleveland?

The West Side Market butchers and the Murray Hill shops in Little Italy. Both grind their own.

Is there a sausage and peppers festival in Cleveland?

The Feast of the Assumption in Little Italy each August is the big one, with street grills running all weekend.

Make it at home instead

You do not need a plane ticket. Larry’s own version takes about forty minutes in a cast-iron pan.

Sausage and peppers in other cities

Elsewhere in USA

Further afield

All 22 city guides →

Join the crew

Join Larry’s email list for future recipes and updates. Newsletter sending has not started yet.

Your address is kept privately. Contact Larry to request removal from the list.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.