Gelato vs Ice Cream

Last updated

The short answer

Gelato is churned slower, so it holds much less air (25–40% vs 80–120% for industrial ice cream, per Carpigiani Gelato University), usually has less fat, and is served warmer. That makes it denser, softer and more intensely flavored. US ice cream must legally have at least 10 percent milkfat. Pick gelato for flavor, ice cream for richness.

Gelato

Italian frozen dessert, typically milk-forward, churned slowly and served soft. Carpigiani gives artisanal gelato a fat range of 0–12%.

Best for

  • • Fruit, nut and coffee flavors
  • • Affogato
  • • A dense, soft scoop that tastes of the flavor

Ice cream

Under US federal rules, ice cream needs at least 10 percent milkfat and must weigh at least 4.5 pounds to the gallon. Industrial ice cream is churned with much more air and served colder.

Best for

  • • Sundaes and pie à la mode
  • • Rich, creamy vanilla and chocolate
  • • Keeping hard in a home freezer

Side by side

GelatoIce cream
Dairy baseUsually more milk than cream (our gelato alla crema uses 500 ml milk to 150 ml cream)Often cream-heavy; US law sets a milkfat minimum
Fat0–12% (artisanal, per Carpigiani)10–20% (industrial, per Carpigiani); US minimum 10 percent milkfat
Air churned in25–40%80–120%
Serving temperature−12 to −14°C (about 7–10°F)−18 to −20°C (about −4 to 0°F)
TextureDense, silky, soft enough to paddleLighter, fluffier, firm enough to scoop round balls
FlavorTastes more intense: less air and fat between you and the flavorRicher and creamier; fat carries the flavor more slowly
At homeLet it soften a few minutes out of a 0°F freezerScoops straight from the freezer after a minute or two
Larry's verdictWhen the flavor is the whole showWhen it's going on top of pie

Air is the big one

Every frozen dessert gets air churned in while it freezes. Carpigiani Gelato University, the training school run by the Italian machine maker, puts artisanal gelato at 25–40% incorporated air and industrial ice cream at 80–120%. More air means a lighter, fluffier scoop. Less air means more actual dessert per spoonful, which is why gelato feels dense and heavy for its size.

Those are typical ranges for artisanal gelato and factory ice cream. A small-batch ice cream shop can churn slower and denser, and some gelato is fluffy. Judge the scoop, not just the name.

Fat: usually less in gelato

The same Carpigiani chart gives artisanal gelato 0–12% fat and industrial ice cream 10–20%. In the US, a product sold as ice cream must contain at least 10 percent milkfat under the federal standard of identity, 21 CFR 135.110, and weigh at least 4.5 pounds to the gallon.

Fat coats your tongue, so lower-fat gelato lets fruit, nut and coffee flavors hit faster. That's the main reason gelato tastes 'more' of what it is.

Gelato is served warmer

Carpigiani lists a serving temperature of −12 to −14°C (about 7–10°F) for gelato and −18 to −20°C (about −4 to 0°F) for industrial ice cream. Warmer means softer and less numbing on the tongue, so you taste more. It's also why gelato shops use flat paddles instead of round scoops.

A home freezer runs around 0°F, colder than a gelato case. Take a tub of gelato out a few minutes before serving.

Is gelato healthier?

Sometimes a scoop has less fat, but it can have just as much sugar, and the denser scoop packs more into the same size. Compare the nutrition labels on the products you actually buy rather than trusting the name.

Common questions

What is the main difference between gelato and ice cream?
Air. Artisanal gelato is churned with 25–40% air and industrial ice cream with 80–120%, per Carpigiani Gelato University. Gelato also usually has less fat and is served warmer.
Does gelato have less fat than ice cream?
Usually. Carpigiani puts artisanal gelato at 0–12% fat and industrial ice cream at 10–20%. US ice cream must have at least 10 percent milkfat.
Why is gelato served warmer?
So it stays soft and the flavor comes through. Carpigiani gives gelato a serving temperature of −12 to −14°C, against −18 to −20°C for industrial ice cream.
Can I use ice cream in an affogato?
Yes. Fior di latte or vanilla gelato is traditional, but a good vanilla ice cream works. It'll just melt a little slower.
Is gelato just Italian for ice cream?
Gelato is the Italian word for it, but in English it usually means the denser, lower-air, softer-served Italian style.

Put it to work

More comparisons

Sources and evidence

Cite this comparison: Gelato vs Ice Cream — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/compare/gelato-vs-ice-cream

Next up

Keep going — a recipe to try, a film to watch, and an answer to the question you were about to search.

Join the crew

Join Larry’s email list for future recipes and updates. Newsletter sending has not started yet.

Your address is kept privately. Contact Larry to request removal from the list.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.