Braised veal shanks in sauce with gremolata

Italian Anniversary Dinner Ideas

Last updated

A celebration dinner for two at home — braised ahead or cooked fast

A first date is about not making mistakes. A proposal is about not getting in the way. An anniversary is the one dinner where the food is allowed to be the point — you already know each other, so cook something that takes a little effort and says so.

Pick one of the two menus below. The braise menu does its work the day before; the quick menu cooks in about half an hour once you're both home. Either way, dessert is made ahead.

The recipes

Two complete menus built from recipes already on the site, each with a make-ahead dessert.

Menu one: braise it the day before

Starter: prosciutto e melone or a fennel and orange salad. Main: osso buco over creamy polenta — the braise tastes better after a night in the fridge, so the day-of job is reheating gently and stirring polenta. Dessert: tiramisù, made the day before.

This is the menu for a weekend anniversary, or for anyone who'd rather spend the evening at the table than the stove.

Menu two: home from work, dinner in 35 minutes

Starter: insalata caprese. Main: veal marsala — or chicken marsala, the same sauce on a cutlet that's easier to find. Serve it with buttered noodles or good bread. Dessert: torta caprese, the flourless chocolate-almond cake, baked the night before.

Veal cooks in about a minute a side; chicken needs a few minutes and has to reach 165°F (74°C).

Menus by milestone: 1st, 5th, 10th, 25th and 50th

The traditional anniversary gift list gives each milestone a material. Emily Post's 1922 Etiquette named paper for the first year, wood for the fifth, tin for the tenth, silver for the twenty-fifth and gold for the fiftieth. Here's a dinner for each, built from recipes already on the site. The themes are a bit of fun; the food is serious.

1st anniversary, paper: roast a whole branzino with lemon and herbs, and for the paper theme, try wrapping it in a parchment packet (the Italian al cartoccio method) to open at the table. Fish is done at 145°F (63°C). Or cook the dish from your first date again and see if it's improved.

5th anniversary, wood: a dinner served on a board. Build a salumi and cheese board as the starter, then pizza slid off a wooden peel, or bruschetta on a cutting board. Tiramisù to finish.

10th anniversary, tin: bake it in a tin. Lasagna alla bolognese in one pan for the main, torta caprese baked the night before in a cake tin for dessert.

25th anniversary, silver: get out the good silverware for the braise menu above, osso buco over polenta, with a Barolo or Barbaresco if it's in the budget.

50th anniversary, gold: osso buco is traditionally served in Milan with golden saffron risotto. We don't have that risotto recipe yet, so polenta stands in. Or turn it into a family dinner: after fifty years there are probably grandchildren who want lasagna. Finish with zabaione, the golden whipped egg custard.

Cook your own history

The best anniversary dish is the one that means something to the two of you: the pasta from the restaurant where you got engaged, the fish from a trip, the dish one of you burned the first time you cooked together. Find the closest recipe on this site and make that the main. Nobody needs a menu more personal than that.

The timeline

Day before: make the dessert. For menu one, braise the osso buco, cool it quickly and refrigerate it in the pot. Day of, an hour out: set the table, chill the sparkling wine, slice the starter. Thirty minutes out: reheat the braise gently until hot throughout, 165°F (74°C), and start the polenta — or, for menu two, pound the cutlets and brown the mushrooms. When you sit down: starter first, then the main, then dessert straight from the fridge.

Wine

Open with something sparkling — Prosecco or Franciacorta. Osso buco is a classic match for structured northern reds like Barolo or Barbaresco; the marsala menu sits well with a lighter red or a fuller white. If the dessert is chocolate, a small glass of Moscato d'Asti or Brachetto d'Acqui is a common suggestion. Keep a zero-proof option chilled too.

Keep cooking

Sources

Food safety: US safe minimum internal temperatures.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good Italian dinner for an anniversary?

A main that feels special plus a make-ahead dessert — for example osso buco with polenta and tiramisù, or veal marsala with torta caprese if you only have half an hour.

What can I make ahead for an anniversary dinner?

Braises like osso buco, and desserts like tiramisù, panna cotta or torta caprese, are all better made the day before. Cool cooked food quickly and refrigerate it within two hours.

Should we cook together or should one person cook?

Either works. The quick marsala menu is easy to split — one person on the cutlets, one on the mushrooms and sauce. The braise menu suits one person cooking the day before as a surprise.

What wine goes with an Italian anniversary dinner?

Sparkling wine to toast, then match the main: a structured red such as Barolo with osso buco, a lighter red or fuller white with marsala. Keep a zero-proof option too.

What should I cook for a 25th or 50th anniversary?

Tie it to the traditional theme if you like: silver for the 25th, so the good silverware and a braise like osso buco; gold for the 50th, so a golden dessert like zabaione, or a family-style lasagna if the whole family is coming.

What's a good first anniversary dinner?

The first anniversary's traditional material is paper, so fish baked in a parchment packet is a fun fit. Or cook the dish from your first date again.

Is there a vegetarian option?

Yes. Swap the main for a mushroom risotto and keep the caprese and dessert. Check the gelatin if you serve panna cotta.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.