Guides · Italian-American history

A Century of Sunday Sauce

Last updated

Short answer

Over a century, the Italian-American Sunday sauce moved from immigrant kitchens to supermarket shelves and back. Early-1900s immigrants made quick tomato sauces from canned tomatoes and could afford more meat; restaurant sauce went home in jars and cans from the 1920s (Chef Boyardee, then Ragu in 1937); the slow Sunday gravy pot became a mid-century ritual and a Godfather scene in 1972; red sauce fell out of fashion in the 1980s and returned upscale in the 2010s.

Slide through the decades. Every fact links to where we found it, and when we couldn’t source a detail for a decade, we left it out instead of guessing. Family recipes vary; this is the documented trail, not anyone’s nonna.

Pick a decade

1900s1 of 13

1900s

The great arrival

The Sunday table

Most Italian Americans were brand-new arrivals: the Library of Congress counts more than two million Italians in the decade after 1900, mostly from the rural south and Sicily. Smithsonian notes that immigrants who had spent about 75 percent of their income on food in Italy spent about 25 percent here, so meat became a staple instead of a rare luxury.source 1source 2

The sauce

A quick tomato sauce. Smithsonian explains that marinara dominated Italian-American home cooking because canned tomatoes and spaghetti were among the few things the groceries had. In New York, importers such as Carlo Aiello brought in Italian canned tomatoes and tomato paste for immigrant kitchens.source 1source 2

Signature dish

Spaghetti and meatballs

Italy had small polpette; the big meatball over spaghetti is American. Smithsonian ties it to the 1880–1920 immigrants, who could afford far more meat here.source

Fields we couldn’t source for this decade are left out rather than guessed.

Common questions

When did Sunday sauce become an Italian-American tradition?

Taste of Home places Sunday gravy in many families' Sunday-morning routine by the mid-20th century, though versions existed earlier, and describes it as adapted from Neapolitan ragù. Smithsonian notes immigrants could afford far more meat in America, which shaped the meaty Italian-American table.

When was jarred spaghetti sauce invented?

Hector Boiardi was selling sauce from his Cleveland restaurant in milk bottles before his company began factory production in 1928. Ragu began as a home business in Rochester, New York, in 1937 and opened its first factory in 1946.

What did Clemenza put in his sauce in The Godfather?

Oil, fried garlic, tomatoes and tomato paste, sausage and meatballs, a little wine and a little sugar.

Why did red sauce go out of style?

The Atlantic described "northern Italian" cooking sweeping American restaurants around 1980, with some advertising "No red sauce." It came back, notably with upscale red-sauce restaurants like Carbone in 2013.

Share or cite this guide

Free to quote with credit and a link back to this page.

Citation

“A Century of Sunday Sauce” — Uncle Larry Adventures, https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/a-century-of-sunday-sauce

Link (HTML)

<a href="https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/a-century-of-sunday-sauce">A Century of Sunday Sauce</a>

Page URL

https://unclelarryadventures.com/guides/a-century-of-sunday-sauce

Sources

Company histories are the companies’ own accounts. More background: Italian food history.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.