Coast to coast · the counters

Famous Italian Delis in America

Last updated

Looking for the best Italian delis in America? Start with the ones that have been slicing the longest. This is a research list of long-running, widely known delis, not a tasting ranking and not a record of Larry's visits. Every fact links to where we found it, almost always the deli's own website. Anything we couldn't confirm is left off.

Quick answer

Famous long-running Italian delis in America include Central Grocery in New Orleans (1906, the muffuletta), Gioia's in St. Louis (since 1918, hot salami), Salumeria Biellese in New York (since 1925), J.P. Graziano in Chicago (since 1937), Di Bruno Bros. in Philadelphia (since 1939), Alidoro in SoHo, Molinari in San Francisco and Bay Cities in Santa Monica (the Godmother). This is a sourced list, not a tasting ranking.

DeliCitySince (as stated)Known for
Central GroceryNew Orleans, LA1906The muffuletta, house-sliced meats and the family's Italian olive salad
Gioia's DeliSt. Louis, MO1918THE ORIGINAL Hot Salami™ sandwich, made with Gioia's own sausage, sliced to order
Salumeria BielleseNew York, NY1925Traditional sausages and salumi from a family descended from the province of Biella, Piedmont
J.P. Graziano GroceryChicago, IL1937Sandwiches, imported Italian groceries and house-made giardiniera
Di Bruno Bros.Philadelphia, PA1939Known as 'The House of Cheese' for its cheese cave, in a roughly 300-square-foot shop
AlidoroNew York, NY1986Named Italian sandwiches, including the Pinocchio, Michelangelo and Pavarotti
Molinari DelicatessenSan Francisco, CANot confirmedItalian dry salame and other cured products
Bay Cities Italian DeliSanta Monica, CANot confirmedThe GODMOTHER: prosciutto, ham, capicola, mortadella, Genoa salami and provolone, 'best with the works'

New Orleans, LA

Central Grocery

Known for
The muffuletta, house-sliced meats and the family's Italian olive salad source
Since
1906, by Sicilian immigrant Salvatore Lupo source
Neighborhood
Decatur Street, French Quarter source

Note: The business says Lupo created the muffuletta. That's the shop's own account, and origin claims like this are often disputed.

Central Grocery website →

St. Louis, MO

Gioia's Deli

Known for
THE ORIGINAL Hot Salami™ sandwich, made with Gioia's own sausage, sliced to order source
Since
Since 1918 (the business's tagline) source
Neighborhood
The Hill source
Address
1934 Macklind Ave, St. Louis, MO 63110 source
Gioia's Deli website →

New York, NY

Salumeria Biellese

Known for
Traditional sausages and salumi from a family descended from the province of Biella, Piedmont source
Since
Hand-crafting salami since 1925 source
Address
378 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001 source
Salumeria Biellese website →

Chicago, IL

J.P. Graziano Grocery

Known for
Sandwiches, imported Italian groceries and house-made giardiniera source
Since
Since 1937; family-owned and operated source
Neighborhood
West Loop source
Address
901 W Randolph St, Chicago, IL 60607 source
Ordering
Online ordering through the shop's website source
J.P. Graziano Grocery website →

Philadelphia, PA

Di Bruno Bros.

Known for
Known as 'The House of Cheese' for its cheese cave, in a roughly 300-square-foot shop source
Since
Original storefront since 1939 source
Neighborhood
The Italian Market source
Address
930 S 9th St, Philadelphia, PA 19147 source
Di Bruno Bros. website →

New York, NY

Alidoro

Known for
Named Italian sandwiches, including the Pinocchio, Michelangelo and Pavarotti source
Since
1986 source
Neighborhood
SoHo source
Address
105 Sullivan Street, New York, NY 10012 source
Alidoro website →

Santa Monica, CA

Bay Cities Italian Deli

Known for
The GODMOTHER: prosciutto, ham, capicola, mortadella, Genoa salami and provolone, 'best with the works' source
Address
1517 Lincoln Blvd, Santa Monica, CA 90401 source
Ordering
The Godmother is made with no substitutions, and online orders run through the shop's ordering site source
Bay Cities Italian Deli website →

What makes it an Italian deli

A salumeria, a grocery and a sandwich counter in one room. Meat and cheese are sliced to order, there's usually something cured or made in-house (salami, sausage, giardiniera, olive salad), and the shelves carry imported pasta, oil and tomatoes. The sandwich is the reason most people walk in. The jar of something you've never seen before is the reason they come back.

Larry's rule: order the thing the place is known for, exactly the way they make it, before you start customizing. If the sign says no substitutions, it means it.

Make the sandwich at home

More deli neighborhoods

From Larry's in-character pilgrimage list. Places to wander, not reviews.

Outside the US

Keep going

Questions about Italian delis

What is the oldest Italian deli in America?
Of the delis on this list, Central Grocery in New Orleans gives the earliest founding date, 1906. 'Oldest' claims for delis are often disputed, and we haven't checked every shop in the country.
What is a famous Italian sandwich in Los Angeles?
Bay Cities' Godmother in Santa Monica: prosciutto, ham, capicola, mortadella, Genoa salami and provolone. The shop says it's made with no substitutions.
What should I order at an Italian deli?
The house sandwich, whatever the shop is known for: a muffuletta at Central Grocery, the Hot Salami at Gioia's, the Godmother at Bay Cities. Then buy whatever they cure or make in-house, like Graziano's giardiniera or Biellese's salumi.
Is this a ranking of the best Italian delis?
No. It's a research list of long-running, widely known delis, with facts from each business's own website. Larry hasn't recorded visits, so there are no scores.
Is it a sub, a hero or a hoagie?
Depends where you're standing: hoagie in Philadelphia, hero in New York, sub in much of the country, grinder in parts of New England. Our hoagie vs hero vs sub guide has the map.

Facts checked against each business's website on 2026-10-24. Hours, menus and addresses change, so check before you go.

Contact Larry

Recipe questions, restaurant tips, gear ideas, press and collabs — send it here.